Archive for category Mia Love

Are Our Public Lands Up For Grabs Now?

High in the Morning - Maynard Dixon

Tea-GOP Congresswoman-elect Mia Love regarding our public lands: “I support returning ownership back to the state of Utah.” The premise of this statement (not to mention the grammar) is completely wrong, because the public lands in Utah have always been in federal ownership since the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo in 1848. The State of Utah did not exist until 1896, nearly a half-century later.

State-level land grab attempts such as the Transfer of Public Lands Act (the 2012 Utah law that demands the federal government hand over public lands to the state by December 31, 2014) violate both the U.S. Constitution and the Utah Constitution. However, the U.S. Congress has the ultimate power over all federal lands. The Property Clause in Article 4 of the Constitution says: “The Congress shall have power to dispose of and make all needful Rules and Regulations respecting the Territory or other Property belonging to the United States…”

Now that the Tea-GOP controls both houses of Congress, will Mia Love get her wish?

Claire Moser on Think Progress:

For the Republican Party, the growing internal debate over whether America’s public lands should be seized and sold represents a choice between the conservation values of Republican President Theodore Roosevelt and the power of a special interest-driven agenda. Former Secretary of the Interior Ken Salazar observed in August that the RNC’s endorsement of land grabs would “cause Teddy Roosevelt to turn over in his grave.”

With the debate escalating over whether public lands should be seized or sold, candidates who dodged the issue but won on Tuesday will likely soon have to say whether they are with the party of Teddy Roosevelt or Cliven Bundy.

President Obama has the power (delegated by Congress to the chief executive in the Antiquities Act of 1906) to proclaim national monuments on public lands. He has already done so 13 times to protect more than 260 million acres of land and water, which is more than any other President. And he says he is “not finished” with national monuments.

There is a proposal for a Greater Canyonlands National Monument in Utah. The Tea-GOP has it coming. Will President Obama bring it?

More info:
The Sagebrush Gang Rides Again? (February 2012)

Is possible San Rafael Swell state park another Utah land grab?


Too Close To Call

Owens and Love

According to the latest Dan Jones and Associates poll, Mia Love has 48 percent with Doug Owens at 43 percent. The five-point spread is roughly equal to the poll’s margin of error, and 6 percent of voters are still undecided. This election could easily go either way. Back in August, Love had a 12-point lead.

Love-Owens poll

Bryan Schott points out that Mia Love has never crossed 50% in any poll, while Doug Owens leads with independents 57% to 29%, and has support from 16% of Republicans.

Love has run a surprisingly lackluster campaign, and has gotten into trouble over false statements – for example, her recent claim that fewer Americans have health insurance now than before the Affordable Care Act was implemented.

What does everyone else think?

Election Results: Mia Love beats Doug Owens 50% to 47%.


%d bloggers like this: